18 Comments
User's avatar
Fernanda Carcamo's avatar

Your lifestream story is terrifying. The ambition for people to pretend to have followers, pretend to be popular, and to live a lie is saddening and worrying. It's a scam that goes beyond the financial gains. It's a personality scam; it's a trust scam; it's a spiritual scam.

May we find our way to reconnect as humans.

Expand full comment
Anglo's avatar

I've seen similar videos, I think the term is "webinar". I've watched a couple out of curiousity. They always talk at a million miles an hour, with grammatically correct sentences, except they discuss nothing, and impart no information.

They use loosely appropriate adjectives to describe vague concepts, and throw around terminology relevant to the video premise (e.g. making money, learning pottery, etc) but in no way actually discussing anything particular about it.

The closest parallel I've seen is in sports commentary or political speech, wherein a segment of time needs to be filled, but there can't be progression or development in the conversation because there's no substance from which to speak. The result is discourse with an aim only to make noise for its own sake.

Expand full comment
Cody Holl's avatar

This is an interesting comparison of The Dead Internet Theory to Avatar The Last Airbender, I loved that show growing up (and still do). I particularly liked the line "In experience, it’s not so much a hypothesis as a state which all online communities exist in to varying degrees at all times."

I've had similar opinions on algorithms, that they aren't just some passive experience, and believe this should be considered by more people. I've had the opinion that social media platforms should be help accountable to some degree for the content they promote and suggest through their suggestion algorithms.

Coincidentally, I also wrote about The Dead Internet Theory in January, if you have the time I'd like to hear what you think of it.

https://open.substack.com/pub/cyberphilosophy/p/the-impending-solipsism-of-the-internet?r=1r9ccy&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

Expand full comment
Erreh Svaia : Meditations's avatar

This is awesome and totally true. Very few people really do interact in internet. Must are just spectators. So mutual of the comments and likes and shit come from bots

Expand full comment
ΟΡΦΕΥΣ's avatar

"A fake outrage presented by the algorithm ... a malicious being that desires to add you to its collection."

... r i g h t .

Expand full comment
shileaux's avatar

This article changed my life. It instantly cured my internet addiction. You posted this on Reddit, and because of you / this article I decided to sign up for substack. Thank you. Please never stop!

Expand full comment
Gracian's Guide's avatar

The way algorithms shape our reactions is unsettling, turning us into unwitting players in a fake narrative.

Expand full comment
the devil's avatar

Fascinating yet so scary, living in an artificial world with no configuration and living activities, you're only on your own in this entirety ecosystem behind the screen, nobody see you, talk to you, everything you see is fake regardless how social they are

Expand full comment
Brandalynn Musk's avatar

I love the image

Expand full comment
Jack Pollard's avatar

Very though provoking read, thanks!!

Expand full comment
Just a Placebo's avatar

"Ohh, but not my feed. My feed is just my personally curated interests that I engage with sparingly." - Faceless Person

Expand full comment
Mohan Bettadpura's avatar

Faceless men and the Thousand faced god -- Game of thrones (Valar Morghulis)

Expand full comment
Fabio's avatar

In the beginning of your text about a livestream, I thought you were gonna talk about red rooms.

Expand full comment
Karma Infinity's avatar

This was a thought-provoking read that captures a quiet truth many feel but rarely articulate—so much of what we experience online feels hollow, curated, or automated. As digital spaces expand, our sense of what’s “real” becomes harder to anchor. It’s a reminder that authenticity isn’t just a feature—it’s a necessity for meaningful connection. In a world flooded with algorithms, sometimes the most radical thing we can do is to be fully human—present, intentional, and real.

Expand full comment
Andrey's avatar

The post wouldn't be so brilliant if it was not brought to me by the Substack algorithm. That makes me wonder if the algorithm is intrinsically evil, and also if this comment has been written by the bot.

Expand full comment
DJK's avatar

I liked your post. I don’t think I’m a bot?

Expand full comment
Mohan Bettadpura's avatar

Altho, how do I believe this post is not by a bot?

Expand full comment